The most dangerous story in your company isn’t the one your competitors are telling the market.
It’s the one you’re telling yourself.
I had two conversations this week. Different industries. Different stages. Different problems. Same disease.
The first was a leader who’s built something real. Revenue is growing. The team is expanding. Clients want more. But when I asked how things were going, she said the same thing she’s said for three years: “We’re still in survival mode.”
She’s not in survival mode. She hasn’t been for a long time.
But the story she told herself when the business was on the edge, the story that helped her push through, never got updated. Now it’s running her company like an outdated operating system.
The second leader looked different on the surface. Sharp. Capable. Deeply knowledgeable. But she kept deflecting her expertise because she was younger than most people in her industry.
“I’m still learning” was her go-to phrase. Not humility. A shield.
And that shield was costing her clients, referrals, and the authority she’d already earned.
Here’s what stopped me cold: both of these leaders knew the story was wrong. When I named it, neither argued. They nodded. They’d heard it before, from their own inner voice.
Knowing and changing are not the same.
What Story Sabotage Actually Is
Story Sabotage happens when a leader’s internal narrative, the story about who they are, where they stand, and what they’re capable of, lags behind reality.
This isn’t imposter syndrome. That’s “I don’t belong here.”
This is worse.
“I belong here, but only if I keep playing the role I was playing two years ago.”
The survival-mode CEO keeps grinding 80-hour weeks because that story kept the company alive. Now it’s what’s keeping it small.
The “still learning” leader defers to less capable people because the story says she hasn’t earned the right to lead. Meanwhile, everyone else already sees her as the leader.
The story was useful once. That’s the trap.
It wasn’t always wrong. It was right for a season.
Seasons change. Narratives don’t update themselves.
Your story becomes your ceiling.
Why CEOs Are Particularly Vulnerable
People assume CEOs are too tough for this. That running a company hardens you against self-deception.
It does the opposite.
CEOs are the most susceptible to Story Sabotage because no one around them is incentivized to challenge their narrative.
Your team won’t tell you. They navigate around the version of you that you project. If you say “we’re in survival mode,” they’ll act like it, even when the numbers say otherwise.
Your board won’t tell you. They see results, not the story underneath.
Your spouse might see it, but they’ve heard the story so many times it sounds true.
So the story sticks.
And it doesn’t just affect you. It shapes the entire organization.
A CEO operating from an outdated narrative builds a culture that mirrors it.
A “survival mode” CEO builds a survival-mode team. Reactive. Risk-averse. Resource-hoarding.
A “still earning my seat” CEO builds a hesitant team. If the leader won’t claim authority, no one else will.
The story you carry becomes the culture you create.
How to Rewrite the Script
You can’t fix what you won’t name.
1. Audit Your Default Phrases
Listen to how you describe your business in casual conversation. Not board meetings. Dinner. Calls. The car.
The phrases you repeat without thinking reveal the story underneath.
“We’re still figuring it out.”
“I’m not there yet.”
“We’re in a tough spot.”
If you’ve said the same thing for six months, it’s not a description. It’s a script.
2. Ask the Timestamp Question
When did this become true?
Is it still true right now?
Most CEOs will find a two-to-three year gap between when the story was accurate and where they are today.
That gap is the cost. Years of operating below your actual capability.
3. Find the Person Who Will Name It
You need someone who can say, “That’s not who you are anymore.”
Not someone who coddles. Not someone who validates everything.
Someone who sees clearly and says it out loud.
Title doesn’t matter. Coach. Peer. Mentor.
Clarity does.
4. Replace, Don’t Just Remove
If you kill a story without replacing it, something else fills the gap. Usually fear.
When you retire a story, install a new one.
“We’re not in survival mode. We’re building.”
“I’m not still learning. I’m leading.”
Say it until it’s true in how you operate.
Call it Straight
Sit with this:
If someone followed you for 30 days and could only learn about your company from how you talk about it, what would they see?
The company you’ve actually built?
Or the one you built three years ago?
The story you tell yourself becomes the strategy you run.
Make sure it’s current.
Leave a Reply